When Is The Right Time To Become An Owner Operator Or Lease A Truck? Never.

by Old School

Forward By Brett Aquila

As many of you know, at TruckingTruth we officially recommend against becoming an owner operator or leasing a truck, especially in your first year on the road. You have entirely too much to learn as it is. The prospect of starting a business in an industry you know nothing about is absurd to say the least.

However, we also recommend against buying or leasing a truck at any stage in your career. Our views draw nearly violent dissent by those who would love nothing more than to brag to their friends that they're The Big Boss Man now who owns that beautiful rig over there.

Hey, we get it! We love rigs as much as anyone. But we'd prefer to make great money, keep the stress levels moderate, eliminate the risk of ownership, and focus on driving while someone else runs the company.

In yet another beautiful rundown by Old School, you're about to read an awesome explanation as to why leasing a truck is far more risky than most people understand.

We also have a conversation started in our forum on this article, so if you'd like to leave a comment please stop on by!

Leave Your Comments About This Article

I am a lifelong entrepreneur. After I retired from thirty years as a business owner, I decided to start driving a truck. So, you see, I came from a business background also. Thirty years of managing as many as ten employees, seven digit sales, and a fleet of six big rigs. I too wanted to start out as an Owner/Operator. I worked hard on putting together a business plan.

Now, I have a lot of experience at laying out projections of costs, sales, and profits. I literally went through my plans frontwards, backward, and sideways. Guess what? The best scenario that I could come up with was that I was going to make about $40,000 a year, and that was if I could consistently haul freight at 1.75/mile. I might be able to make a little bit more than that, but basically I was breaking even at 1.75/mile and paying myself a $40,000 salary - there really were no profits left after that.

Now when I projected that out to somewhere in the five or six year distance and taking into account whether I would be needing to either do some major overhauls to my truck, or try to buy a new one, guess where that money would have to come from? Out of my annual salary that I had been making, of $40,000 for the past year!

Now, if you think that sounds good, then I'm all for you to go out there and break your neck doing it. Here's the real problem with this whole thing of being an Owner Operator - it ends up being an emotional decision rather than a logical one that looks realistically at the possibilities for profits or losses.

About half of the O/O's I've spoken with regret their decision, and realized a little too late what they've gotten themselves into. The other half are just outright obliviously stubborn, and are going to grind it out until the bitter end finally rises up and slaps them down completely. If you are the type that just thinks it's "cool" to have a nice rig, and likes to be seen as "cool" by your peers, then you may enjoy being an owner operator for a little while, but it will be short lived. You will soon discover that there is nothing "cool" about chasing down a broker who owes you money, when you could be spending your precious time in a much better way.

The Competition Is Cutthroat In Trucking

One thing that newbies jumping into this business don't think about is just how cutthroat the competition is. Owner Operators have got to find niche markets to get into if they even have a prayer at success. Guess what? Everyone is eyeing those niche markets nowadays. J.B. Hunt has specialized in that kind of thing for years. So now all the little guys are having to try to compete with the big players like Schneider, Swift, Prime, etc... If you don't think that someone else will jump in and cut your bids for freight just to run a few more loads on their trucks, you are willfully blind.

When I came up with my own scenarios for running loads, and knew that I needed to charge at least 1.75 per mile, I then started researching what loads were going for around the country. Well, that was a shocking revelation! Some of these big time carriers were doing them for sometimes as low as 1.10-1.25 per mile! Not only that, they were getting huge discounts on fuel, tires, and maintenance that I had zero leverage to negotiate for. It is a commodities business - in a nutshell, that means that the cheapest price gets the bid. It literally is a game of making pennies out here in the very vicious world of trucking.

Research The Profit Statements Of Large Carriers

Now, if you choose to think I am a nut and don't have a clue about what I am talking about, you should look up some of these very large trucking companies and do a little research into what their operating ratios are. These are publicly traded companies, and you can find this information easily, because investors need to know these types of things before they will part with their money. Many of them have an Operating Ratio of 97%. In layman's terms that means that for every dollar they take in, they get to keep three pennies of it. These are some of the best managed trucking companies in the world, and that is why they have people willing to invest in them. They have the best and the brightest people doing everything they can to make sure that they can at least keep three out of every 100 pennies they generate in revenues.

Many Reasons To Remain A Company Driver

A lot of the folks in here who have given you advice have said you should get your feet wet first, and then try being an Owner Operator. I actually disagree with all that, and here's why. A little more than four years ago, I started out as a company driver, learned the business, and concentrated my efforts at becoming the best I could be at this. Today, I am making about thirty thousand more dollars a year than I could pencil out for my salary when I was formulating my business plan as an Owner/Operator, plus I have all the benefits of health insurance, company matched 401K plan, paid vacations, and if my truck is ever down, they just put me in another one so that neither I nor they are losing money.

This business is very tough, and it doesn't care one bit about who it spits out and leaves behind. There are a lot better ways to make money in business if you just want to be in business for yourself. Trucking has such slim margins and such fierce competitors in the field that it takes a really hard headed nut to try and stand out as something special in a field that literally leaves no room for distinction.

Don't end up like the one Owner Operator that I spoke with who knew exactly what was going on with his business. He even gave his trucking company a name that reflected the reality that he was facing day in and day out as he ran his own trucking business. Here's a look at his truck. I'm hoping you don't end up doing just what he was doing in his business...


Leave Your Comments About This Article

Owner Operator:

An owner-operator is a driver who either owns or leases the truck they are driving. A self-employed driver.


Hours Of Service

HOS refers to the logbook hours of service regulations.


When a violation by either a driver or company is confirmed, an out-of-service order removes either the driver or the vehicle from the roadway until the violation is corrected.

by Brett Aquila

Related Articles:

How Do I Know If Truck Driving Is For Me?

by Brett Aquila

We've all pondered becoming a truck driver at some point in our lives. But what is it really like? Would it suit me? Here's a great introduction to truck driving.

Bureaucracy And Unfair Expectations Plague Today's Truck Drivers

by Becky Prestwich

The trucking industry has an avalanche of rules and regulations, stereotypes and expectations for truck drivers to deal with. Here's the reality we face.

Leasing A Truck: Do The Rewards Justify The Risks?

by Brett Aquila

Trucking companies often make owning or leasing a truck sound like a sure path to riches. But a closer look reveals it isn't nearly that simple.

Is Trucking Worth It Anymore?

by Brett Aquila

The risk, pressure, and sacrifices involved make trucking a tough job but the perks that come along with it are remarkable. Is trucking worth it anymore?

Confessions Of An Owner Operator

by Old School

Most owner operators famously exaggerate their profitability numbers, but a few gave us the real scoop, and here's what they had to say...

Trucking Is A Competition Between Drivers. Can You Hang With The Big Dogs?

by Old School

It's not a huge stretch to compare the trucking industry, a completely performance based enterprise, to the business of professional sports.

Old School Responds To Criticisms After Busting The Free Agency Myth

by Old School

Old School wrote an article dispelling the free agency myth in trucking and received an irate response. Here is Old School's reply to the criticism.

Sexism In Trucking From A Woman's Perspective

by Rainy

I am often asked about what it is like to be a woman trucker. It takes a special woman to handle it, but I love it. Here is my experience as a woman truck driver.

The Web Of Lies And Misinformation

by G-Town

If you look around the Web, you'll find tons of bad information, outright lies, and half truths about the trucking industry. In today's Web, who can you trust?

Scared Of That Perverted, Creepy Trainer?

by Rainy

I've faced sexual harassment in trucking. I handled it well and made it through unharmed. Here is my story and some advice for women drivers.

Join Us!

We have an awesome set of tools that will help you understand the trucking industry and prepare for a great start to your trucking career. Not only that, but everything we offer here at TruckingTruth is 100% free - no strings attached! Sign up now and get instant access to our member's section:
High Road Training Program Logo
  • The High Road Training Program
  • The High Road Article Series
  • The Friendliest Trucker's Forum Ever!
  • Email Updates When New Articles Are Posted

Apply For Paid CDL Training Through TruckingTruth

Did you know you can fill out one quick form here on TruckingTruth and apply to several companies at once for paid CDL training? Seriously! The application only takes one minute. You will speak with recruiters today. There is no obligation whatsoever. Learn more and apply here:

Apply For Paid CDL Training

About Us

TruckingTruth was founded by Brett Aquila (that's me!), a 15 year truck driving veteran, in January 2007. After 15 years on the road I wanted to help people understand the trucking industry and everything that came with the career and lifestyle of an over the road trucker. We'll help you make the right choices and prepare for a great start to your trucking career.

Read More

Becoming A Truck Driver

Becoming A Truck Driver is a dream we've all pondered at some point in our lives. We've all wondered if the adventure and challenges of life on the open road would suit us better than the ordinary day to day lives we've always known. At TruckingTruth we'll help you decide if trucking is right for you and help you get your career off to a great start.

Learn More