I've been thinking about a conversation I had about a year ago with an Owner Operator who was parked along side me in a small truck stop in Delhi, Louisiana. It was refreshing to hear someone who seemed to genuinely know what he was talking about, and wasn't trying to blow smoke screens with misleading and convoluted numbers of which I've already unearthed the fallacies of. It made me think about the various things I have heard different Owner Operators say over the years, and I thought it might be beneficial to some of you who are thinking about becoming an owner operator if I put a collection together of the confessions I've heard.
I consider the financial risks that an Owner Operator takes on himself to far outweigh the limited possibility of a long term strategy for profits.
- Old School
Let me preface all this with my position on why it is best not to become an owner operator. After having owned a small fleet of big trucks in a manufacturing business I was involved in for many years, I feel I learned a good deal about truck ownership. It is a costly endeavor to own and maintain a Class 8 vehicle, and while they are great pieces of equipment to generate nice amounts of "cash flow," they are really tough to generate sizable amounts of profit with. They are an asset that depreciates very quickly, and the effects of wear and tear on them tends to compound with both age and use. In short, they need to be replaced fairly often, and that in itself is a huge encumbrance to a long term strategy of producing worthwhile profits. The asset that an owner operator bases his profits on is steadily and rapidly decreasing in value, and efficiency.
Have you ever noticed how so many of the large truck load carrier's recruiting messages include making a point about how often they replace their equipment? Very seldom will you find a major trucking business keeping trucks more than four, or five years old. I've been in my current company truck for three years and a few months now. In just a few more months I will have over 500,000 miles on the odometer. At that point it will be considered as an asset to be sold, not maintained.
Now if you look at the average Owner Operator they will keep their trucks for many more years due to the high replacement costs, and according to well established numbers developed by the trucking industry, they are cutting into their efficiency and profitability by keeping their trucks on the road for much longer periods of time. How is it that the most successful tucking businesses in the country will go to all the expense of replacing their equipment at benchmark mileage levels so that they can remain profitable, yet owner operators will sometimes keep a truck until is held together with bailing wire and bubblegum? Just take a look at some of the trucks that many of these guys pulling containers from the ports are driving, and you will see what I'm talking about.
I'm sorry, I have strayed from giving you my position on why I believe it best to remain a company driver, but I have developed a little bit of background information for you to see why I take the position I do. Basically, I consider the financial risks that an Owner Operator takes on himself to far outweigh the limited possibility of a long term strategy for profits. I am making some really good solid money as a company driver. I found a niche with a company that works well for me, and I have been developing that strategy for my continued success as a company driver. It is really that simple – no financial risks or headaches, and all the money that I get paid is truly mine.
Okay, so the gentleman with whom I had this conversation which inspired these thoughts was 67 years old and had been leased on with LandStar for 23 years. I think that gives him some degree of credibility – he is no greenhorn just seeing dollar signs – he is well established at this gig. I am pulling some of his comments from my original post in our forum about a year ago.
Listen to some of the things he said to me...
"...the money was not really any better than being a good company driver, but he does it so that he can be home every weekend (something you can accomplish as a company driver also) and he wanted to run in a certain area of the country - the south." He lives in Alabama.
He acknowledged that when he first started out as an owner operator those things were his goals, but that:
"...there are plenty of company positions which offer regional runs with those options available"
He told me that his wife tells him that he's:
"...not doing any better than he did when he was a company driver years ago, and that as best as they can figure the money part of it, they are enjoying having an expensive hobby."
That is the way he described it to me - an expensive hobby! It is rare that I meet with such candor from an owner operator, and I enjoyed talking to him. It was nice not having him try to convince me of the pie in the sky scenarios when it is something that I already have an understanding about.
He ended the conversation with a comical little remark about his nice big sleeper on his 1993 Peterbilt wagon. He said that:
...originally the truck had a regular sleeper, and he wanted to get one of those really nice big ones. His wife was against it because of the incredible expense of it. He convinced her to let him spend some more money on their "hobby" by telling her this: "Well, you know honey, I have only got two vices. That is big trucks and little women. Somehow after all these years I've ended up with a little truck and a big woman!"
Haha! After that comment she gave him permission to go ahead and have his big truck!
He did have a nice looking Peterbilt truck, with one of those grandiose sleepers on it, but if you look at what he is saying, it sounds as if they are sinking everything they've got into their "expensive hobby." Remember the thoughts I shared with you earlier about the expense involved of replacing worn equipment? Here I was having this conversation with this guy and I, the lowly company driver, am driving really brand new state of the art equipment, while he is driving a 1993 model truck that is 23 years old!
Do you realize just how expensive it is for an owner operator to suffer the down time for repairs? As a one truck operation there is nothing coming in for revenues when you are down, but that never ending outflow of cash for payments and insurance, overhead, and personal bills never stops or slows down.
See also: Leasing A Truck: Do The Rewards Justify The Risks? by Brett Aquila
I want you to see some of the other "confessions" that the discussion in our forum brought out from our members. Take a look at what "Bud" had to say. Bud was a hard working individual who had leased a truck from a major carrier, and was always honest with us about his experience. He did a fine job of it, but he felt like he came up short after it was all said and done.
"All I'm going to say is I have a lot of business experience, I tried leasing (granted, not the best lease program available, but probably about average), and everything Old School and Brett warned about came true. It was pretty good for a while, then pretty bad, and now they're still trying to get money from me four months after I left!"
Then there was this interesting response from Brian, another lease operator in our forum, who started out well at this early stage of his experience, acknowledged that the failure rate is really high...
"Bud sorry it didn't work out for you, failure rate is pretty high. You're story is probably more the norm than mine."
In fact, Brian acknowledged that failure is more the norm! Do you really want to take a leap into a business model where the few people who are pulling it off acknowledge such things about it?
Let's pull a few more confessions from our forum conversations that were put there by well meaning advocates of truck ownership/leasing. I just want you to read them for yourselves and make up your own mind whether this really sounds desirable to you or not. All of these "confessions" are gleaned from owner operators/lease operators who made these comments during discussions in our forum...
"I am out for 12 to 16 weeks at a shot, I rarely see a 34 and the truck never stops moving more than 4 to 6 hours."
"I finally felt comfortable enough to take 3 weeks off. My truck never stopped moving though. I just came back to work and I am 52 dollars in the negative. Before I took off my co driver took 3 weeks off as well. Now I'm back and will run till The end of October with my co driver." (this comment was made in the month of July)
This comment was made six months into the year:
"So far this year leasing my fixed and variable costs are 82,000"
"In the past 2 years I've put 450000 miles on my freightliner."
I found this one intriguing, since so many people use the excuse of wanting more control over their home time as a reason to be an owner operator:
"we are on week 12 since home time"
So, there you have it. Some interesting confessions that I found right in our own forum conversations from well meaning owner operators who are living the life. I leave the determination up to you as to whether this is a good investment of your time and treasure. For me it is clearly not worth it. I make great money, have all kinds of privileges that the top drivers get from their dispatchers, and I go home when requested. I am living large on this job, and I have only to answer to myself when it comes to the amount of success I experience at this. I can't think of any other form of employment that has more to offer in terms of freedom to choose how I want to manage it, and I get to measure out my own income by my performance. Man, this is a lot like being self-employed without all the headaches and worry. I'll take that any day!
Usually refers to a driver hauling freight within one particular region of the country. You might be in the "Southeast Regional Division" or "Midwest Regional". Regional route drivers often get home on the weekends which is one of the main appeals for this type of route.
An owner-operator is a driver who either owns or leases the truck they are driving. A self-employed driver.
OOIDA is an international trade association representing the interests of independent owner-operators and professional drivers on all issues that affect truckers. The over 150,000 members of OOIDA are men and women in all 50 states and Canada who collectively own and/or operate more than 240,000 individual heavy-duty trucks and small truck fleets.
The mission of OOIDA is to serve owner-operators, small fleets and professional truckers; to work for a business climate where truckers are treated equally and fairly; to promote highway safety and responsibility among all highway users; and to promote a better business climate and efficiency for all truck operators.
A truck drivers DAC report will contain detailed information about their job history of the last 10 years as a CDL driver (as required by the DOT).
It may also contain your criminal history, drug test results, DOT infractions and accident history. The program is strictly voluntary from a company standpoint, but most of the medium-to-large carriers will participate.
Most trucking companies use DAC reports as part of their hiring and background check process. It is extremely important that drivers verify that the information contained in it is correct, and have it fixed if it's not.
When a violation by either a driver or company is confirmed, an out-of-service order removes either the driver or the vehicle from the roadway until the violation is corrected.
by Brett Aquila
Many people consider owning their own truck. In this article we'll discuss the difficulties involved.
What comes after the first year of truck driving? You have a lot of new options open, including leasing a truck or becoming an owner operator.
by Corporal Clegg
I signed the lease agreement with my company and for the first time I head out onto the highway in my leased tractor trailer. Now the adventure begins
by Brett Aquila
Trucking companies often make owning or leasing a truck sound like a sure path to riches. But a closer look reveals it isn't nearly that simple.
by Old School
At TruckingTruth we recommend against becoming an owner operator or leasing a truck. The risks are high and the rewards are few, if any. Here's our thinking on the matter.
by Old School
Is becoming an owner operator really a step up in your trucking career or are you walking off a cliff? What is the pinnacle of success in trucking?
by Old School
Old School wrote an article dispelling the free agency myth in trucking and received an irate response. Here is Old School's reply to the criticism.
by Old School
I went through a lot of difficulties at the start of my trucking career. I hope to show you can still succeed and enjoy this career even after a rough start.
by Old School
Many people want to get into trucking as local drivers, but a rookie driver isn't ready for the demands of local trucking jobs. Here's why you should start OTR.
Most people feel a lot of pressure before the CDL driving exam. We're here to tell you that failing is not a big deal. It happened to me. Here's my story.
Click Anywhere To Close