News, Interviews, and Happenings From The Trucking World
ELDs might not be the panacea that was hoped for
Truck drivers may soon see "phantoms" driving yard trucks
Friday Short Haul - Nikola big rigs, WIT welcomes Peterbilt, Oregon crashes, Border crossings
Carriers claim financial benefit of putting up drivers in hotels
Uber's IPO application reveals interesting data about its freight brokerage business
Friday Short Haul - CDL examiner arrested, tolls proposed for trucks, marijuana use on the rise
Smart Load Board will get carriers the loads they need
Huge lines and long wait times greet carriers at Mexico border
Friday Short Haul - Marijuana, ATA campaign, personal conveyance rules
Over-the-air downloads revolutionize parameter updates
Don't get scammed by skimmers
Friday Short Haul -- New Cascadias honored, motorist survey, U.S, Xpress awarded, rest stop parking
Legislators address underride collisions, propose more underguards for trucks, trailers
Motorists soon may encounter a different kind of truck convoy
Friday Short Haul -- Women in Trucking, irate motorist, FMCSA eases HOS, Safe-Cap
Recent survey shows cost of roadside repairs is rising
FMCSA announces drug and alcohol clearinghouse website
Friday Short Haul - Swift settlement, driver shortage myth, TCA Best Fleet award
The hidden danger of looking but not seeing
Accident scammers target trucks for financial payout
Friday Short Haul - Snow on the roof, bypassing toll road, Waze under fire
Retailers blame driver shortage for price increases
Drivers' smartphones may be clue to road roughness
Friday Short Haul -- Freight rates, HOS changes, tonnage reports
New tax changes hit drivers hard
FMCSA to implement under-21 interstate driver program for former military
Friday Short Haul -- Connecticut tolls proposed, hydrogen fuel-cell trucks, cell phone use
Congress committee looks at state of America's highways
Number of cargo thefts is down; but dollar value about the same
Friday Short Haul -- Crossing the border, CA sues FMCSA, Lobbying against larger trucks
Detention - A problem still in search of a solution
February Highway Angels honorees named
Friday Short Haul -- C.R. England announces pay raises, eCommerce impact on trucking, TCA announces best fleets
Is a guaranteed minimum pay the solution to the driver shortage?
Long CDL testing wait times cost economy billions of dollars; not helping driver shortage
Friday Short Haul -- Walmart hiring, Uber Freight App, Speed-limiter Law, America's Road Team
Cranking -- The Good, The Bad, and the Ugly
California survives challenge to its low-carbon fuel standards
Friday Short Haul - Highway robbery ... autonomous trucks ... new trailers
LithiumHub enters jump-starter market with Jumpbooster JP30
2019 Looks Good For The Transportation Industry
Raymond Burt named TMC Trainer of the Month for February 2018
TMC Transportation Announces Recipient of Prestigious Wheel Master Award
TMC Transportation Named The Home Depot’s Flatbed Carrier of the Year For Fourth Straight Year
Pay Raises & New Peterbilts for PAM Drivers
New DOT Drug Testing Rules Effective Jan 1, 2018
Amtrak Derailment: Trucks Haul 270,000 Pound Locomotive Engine During Cleanup
Pepsi Places Largest Order Yet For Tesla Electric Trucks
Kavin Hallett named Trainer of the Month for October 2017
Over 100,000 Truck Drivers Likely Have Undiagnosed Sleep Apnea And More Testing Is On The Way
Drivers Share Their Best Tips, Tricks, And Secrets For Life On The Road
Drivers Are Losing Money By Taking The Wrong Approach
Truckers and Guns: What Is and Is Not Legal
Preparing To Go Solo For The First Time? Experienced Drivers Share Their Best Advice
The Truck Stop Survival Guide: Advice From Experienced Drivers
The Worst Cities For Traffic In The U.S. For 2017
We Ask Drivers How They Would Make The Logbook Rules Better
Self Driving Trucks Are Not Coming Anytime Soon
Detention - A problem still in search of a solution
Last Updated: Tue, February 12, 2019
Detention, the on-duty but not-driving time a driver spends waiting at a shipper or receiver, is a necessary evil in the trucking industry, but the consensus among drivers is that there should be compensation to the driver for the time he has to spend cooling his heels at a facility.
In this installment of Trucking Truth News we'll take a look at detention in terms of how bad the problem is for drivers, what an equitable detention pay should be and what is being done about it.
Those waits can be long, and costly to drivers.
Citing a typical wait, for example, FreightWaves chief insight officer Dean Croke says he has to spend six or seven hours on most Sundays waiting for grocery loads.
A FreightWaves Sonar research project found that in 2018 drivers spent an average of 2 ½ hours waiting at shippers and receivers; which resulted in some $1.3 billion in lost wages for those drivers.
Those times vary by location. FreightWaves found average waits as high as 5 ½ hours. Here are ranked cities with the 10 worst average wait times out of the 135 surveyed:
- 10. Laredo, Texas — an average of 212 minutes
- 9. Fort Wayne, Indiana — an average of 223 minutes
- 8. Little Rock, Arkansas — an average of 230 minutes
- 7. Duluth, Minnesota — an average of 231 minutes
- 6. Shreveport, Louisiana — an average of 237 minutes
- 5. El Paso, Texas — an average of 253 minutes
- 4. South Bend, Indiana — an average of 267 minutes
- 3. Rochester, New York — an average of 279 minutes
- 2. Erie, Pennsylvania — an average of 323 minutes
- 1. Fresno, California — an average of 331 minutes
Chad Boblett, owner and driver with Boblett Brothers Trucking of Lexington, Kentucky, in a blog article last year for DAT, admits that, "Some amount of detention may be unavoidable, and the broker can’t always influence what happens at the shipper’s or receiver’s dock. But carriers and drivers can still ask for fair treatment, including fair compensation for long delays."
Boblett, who deals with brokers for his loads, says getting detention pay can "involve some drama." These are also familiar to company drivers.
- The broker paying after three hours of detention instead of two hours, or not paying at all.
- Having to nag the broker repeatedly to add detention to the contract.
- In and out times must be signed by the shipping/receiving office, but frequently office people fail to do so.
- Doing everything right, but when the paycheck comes the detention pay is mysteriously missing.
Boblett offers advice, particularly for owner-operators, but this advice could be a heads-up for company drivers as well. Company drivers typically can't refuse loads, but they can use this advice in their planning.
- Watch out for a "first-come, first-served" policies from a facility. This could mean they do not intend to pay detention, and you could be in for a long wait time.
- Read DAT Company reviews.
- Ask the broker/carrier about detention. A red flag could be if they try to side-step talking about it.
- Make sure to negotiate detention in writing. If the broker/carrier does not want to do this, it's another red flag.
There's also a problem of driver safety. According to KeepTruckin, drivers hit with a 2-hour or longer detention know they must still make their delivery on time, so they will drive an average of 3.5 mph faster to make up for lost time once they hit the road.
The Department of Transportation took a look at detention time in relation to crash rates and found that every 15-minute increase in average detention time resulted in an increase in the average expected crash rate by 6.2 percent.
Many carriers offer their company drivers some form of detention pay. The typical detention formula is that the first two hours the driver has to wait is without pay. Then, the third and subsequent hours will earn the driver $20 or more per hour.
So, a three-hour detention works out to $6.67 per hour at the $20 rate. But, even if the driver is lucky enough to be driving for a carrier that offers $50/hour detention a three hour wait computes to only $16.67 an hour -- barely more than minimum wage these days.
Drivers, especially independent owner-operators, report that detention pay is hard to come by. DAT Solutions conducted a survey of 257 trucking companies and found that only 3 percent of drivers reported receiving detention pay for at least 90 percent of their claims to shippers.
Todd Dill, a writer for Overdrive, cited an Overdrive poll where 38 percent of drivers suggested detention pay be equal to total revenue per mile, and 45 percent of drivers suggested a calculation (for owner-operator drivers) of profit from net income per mile plus their fixed cost per mile.
Overdrive reported that for the average owner-operator detention pay calculated that way would come to $64 per hour.
In recent news, U.S. District Judge Timothy Brooks in Arkansas reaffirmed on January 25 an earlier ruling that a trucking company that didn't pay its drivers at least a minimum wage for on-duty time spent not driving is in violation of the Fair Labor Standards Act.
The ruling followed a class-action lawsuit by some 3,000 PAM Transport drivers. Brooks had ruled back in October 2018 that PAM must pay its drivers at least minimum wage for 16 hours each day that they work.
The ruling, however, is likely to be appealed. Angela Clark, vice president for risk management for PAM Transport, said, "We are very disappointed with the court's ruling and respectfully disagree with the court's holdings. We plan to vigorously fight this, including review of the court's decision."
But the ruling is now being used as precedent as other carriers come under the gun by drivers demanding pay for on-duty time not driving.
Some 10,000 Swift Transport truck drivers used Brooks' ruling to bolster their complaint that the carrier has violated labor laws by not paying them for some training and orientation sessions.
Other recent cases where carriers had to pony up back pay to their drivers include one in 2017 where a Nebraska court ruled in favor of 52,000 student drivers against Werner Enterprises, which had to pay out a total of $780,000 for pay practice violations. And another against C.R. England in 2016 which had to pay some $2.35 million in back wages to more than 6,000 drivers.
In answer to threats of appeals, Judge Brooks remains firm in his ruling:
"There is no ambiguity here, then, as to whether an employer must count as hours worked the time that an employee spends riding in a commercial truck while neither sleeping nor eating: time thus spent is working and any work performed while traveling must ... be counted as hours worked."
Sources: Business Insider,
Hours Of Service
Life On The Road
Truck Driver Safety
Trucking Industry Concerns